Peter’s Pizzeria – Pompano Beach, FL
Authentic New York-style pizza in the heart of Pompano Beach. Founded in 2019 by Long Island-born pizzaiolo Peter Izzo, our Pompano Beach flagship serves hand-tossed, seed-oil-free pies that bring the boardwalk slice straight to South Florida. Dine-in, pickup, delivery, and full-service catering – seven days a week (closed Mondays).
Why Locals Choose Peter’s Pizzeria Pompano
Hand-tossed, cold-fermented dough with the exact snap and chew of a Long Island slice – no Florida-ized shortcuts.
No canola, no soybean, no corn oil. We cook with real ingredients the way pizza should be made.
Peter trained in Florence and worked Long Island pizzerias since his teens. Every pie is built with that obsession.
Consistent reviews from New Yorkers, New Jerseyans, and Floridians who’ve tried the rest and come back to Peter’s.
Dine-in with the whole family, grab a slice at the counter, or rent the entire pizzeria for a private event.
Convenient parking right off N Federal Hwy. Quick in-and-out for delivery pickups.
Our Menu Highlights
Signature Pies
- The CPR (Chicken, Prosciutto, Ranch)
- Vodka Eggplant Slice
- Classic NY Cheese
- Grandma-style Square
- Margherita (DOP tomatoes, fresh mozz)
Sandwiches & Piadina
- Italian Piadina (our “Italian taco”)
- Meatball Parm Hero
- Chicken Cutlet Hero
- Eggplant Parm Hero
- Capicola & Fresh Mozz
Sides & Apps
- Fried Ravioli
- Homemade Meatballs
- Sautéed Spinach
- Caesar & Mixed Green Salads
- Garlic Knots
How to Get Peter’s Pompano
Dine In
Tue-Sun
Family-friendly
Pickup
Order online
Ready in 15-25 min
Delivery
SpotOn & 3rd-party apps
Catering
Parties & corporate
Book the Shop
Rent the full pizzeria
Hours – Pompano Beach
Neighborhoods We Serve
Our Pompano Beach pizzeria is a favorite spot for locals and visitors from across Broward County. We serve pizza lovers from Pompano Beach, Lighthouse Point, Deerfield Beach, Fort Lauderdale, Oakland Park, Wilton Manors, and Coconut Creek. If you’re driving up A1A or passing through on Federal Highway, stop in for a slice. Heading south? Visit our Boca Raton location at 897 E Palmetto Park Rd.
Pompano Beach FAQs
Do you deliver in Pompano Beach?
Yes. Order directly through our online ordering system (SpotOn) for the best experience, or use DoorDash/Uber Eats/Grubhub. Delivery radius covers most of Pompano Beach, Lighthouse Point, and parts of Deerfield Beach.
Is Peter's Pompano really seed-oil-free?
Yes. We cook everything with quality oils – no canola, soybean, corn, or vegetable oil anywhere in our kitchen. This is part of our commitment to real ingredients and authentic NY-style pizza.
Can I book the whole pizzeria for a private event?
Absolutely. We host birthdays, corporate gatherings, baptisms, and family parties in Pompano. Call (954) 933-7333 to discuss availability.
Do you offer gluten-free crust?
Call the shop at (954) 933-7333 for current gluten-free and dietary options – we rotate offerings and can accommodate most requests with advance notice.
What are Peter's busiest hours?
Friday and Saturday dinner (6 PM – 9 PM) are our peak. If you want a faster experience, try Tuesday-Thursday evenings or lunchtime any day. Online ordering for pickup is always the fastest.
Is there parking?
Yes – we have parking right at 1166 N Federal Hwy for both dine-in guests and quick pickup orders.